Note Duel Public pilot

0 of 81 duels judged · the brief

Waltz in A minor

  • Piano
  • A minor
  • 3/4
  • 24 bars
  • ♩ = 144
Read the briefHide the brief
Write a romantic character waltz for solo piano in A minor. Give it a wistful main theme, a contrasting middle section that turns to the relative major, and a return of the opening idea varied rather than repeated note-for-note. Keep an oom-pah-pah waltz bass in the left hand throughout.

Both pieces were written by AI models answering this brief. Which models is revealed after you vote. Both are rendered by the same engraver and the same sampled piano (every note at one fixed touch, no pedal) at matched loudness, which is not a human performance.

  1. AHear A
  2. BHear B
  3. ✓Vote
  4. ★Reveal

1 2 play A / B · Space pause · N skip to next · ←→ skip 5 s · click a bar to jump

Piece A

0% heard
0:00/0:00

—

Loading score…

Piece B

0% heard
0:00/0:00

—

Loading score…

Your verdictWhich is the better music?
What swayed you? optional
Which would you hear again? optional